Relationship Advice?

ScaredToBreathe

Well-known member
I don't have any friends or anyone I feel comfortable talking to about this, so I am hoping you guys could give me some advice, opinions, or your past experiences. I have been in a relationship for about 3 years but for the past few months I have been thinking of whether I should break it off or not. I have no idea whether that would help or hurt me in the long run.

So we've had a pretty good relationship and have lived together for most of it (and are still living together). He was my first serious and long-term relationship, first true love, first person I've lived together with, and first (and only) intimate partner. I know he loves me, he has never cheated or been interested in anyone else, and he has never abused me in any way. He also knows I get very depressed and sometimes anxious and he is very supportive and empathetic about that; he has never made me feel ashamed about my disorders.

However, during the time we've been together he has not been able to get a job. He has tried applying to places and even going to interviews, but never lands a job. But he has barely any work experience and does not use employment opportunity/guidance resources available to him. He makes a low amount of money currently and is terrible managing his finances, we have talked about this and even worked out a budget to follow but he still spends all his money on things that aren't necessary. He has zero savings, is usually late to pay rent, and many times can't even come up with his share to pay for things like groceries (and owes me money for covering some of his expenses when he wasn't making enough to pay for himself, although he does pay me back small amounts when he can and has been trustworthy about it). This makes it very stressful on me, as I am a student and only work a part-time min wage job. I haven't even had enough to buy groceries the past few weeks and have been eating barely anything, or buying cheap snacks to eat when I can.

He also does not get things done that need to be done. For example: not cleaning up after himself regularly, not helping with household chores, not keeping track of important documents and things (he has a habit of losing/misplacing things), not saving enough funds to help with our monthly expenses, and not getting around to things he said he will do (either for himself or me, or both of us). Even when I remind him about things or ask him for help with something, he will say yes he will get it done but he never does. I also hate complaining and nagging him about things but he just never seems to take action or have any motivation to change. It is very frustrating.

I have talked with him multiple times about these issues and he says he knows and he's trying and feels bad and that he will try to change, etc. But things just stay the same, no matter what I tell him or do for him. I have also tried helping him many, many times to try to make things easier on him, including getting him job interviews, helping him with his resume, taking him out on dates/to do something together, helping him organize things and getting information/doing research on things for him to reach his goals, encouraging him, finding helpful/supportive resources or services he can use, etc. (He won't do these things himself!)

I know him well and I can see he wants to help. He is not using me or having bad intentions. He is a genuinely nice and caring person but he has difficulty getting started on things and achieving goals/being productive. He is in his mid-twenties and does not know what he wants as a career or how to go about finding the right path. (I can't even think of anything he would do well at and enjoy, especially because he never really did well in school subjects and does not have any passions that might guide him to a certain career, though he does want to go back to school...he just doesn't know for what.)

Sorry this is so long. It is complicated for me. Basically, our relationship isn't terrible, but it is not great either. I've done everything I can and given him lots of time but he still hasn't changed his ways. I am not sure if I love him anymore, but my life has also been very stressful lately so that may be why I feel a lack of emotion. I definitely don't feel like dating anyone else. If we broke up, I know I'd be depressed and would not want to date for a long time. I do care about him and enjoy being around him. We also share similar interests and get along well; we don't have many fights or anything and have mutual understanding of one another. He is also my best and only friend and the person I confide in the most, so it would be hard on me to let that go. I have tried to make new friends but it hasn't worked out, and I don't have anyone. I would move back in with my parents if we broke up and I think that would be less stressful. I do feel fed up and like I've done every possible thing I could to help my boyfriend be more productive and to make things work out living like this. Stress and frustration has been taking its toll on me and I do not feel a strong emotional connection with my boyfriend like I used to. I have told him how I feel and that I am done. I have told him how frustrated I am and what issues I have. He didn't respond much, just asked why and seemed confused and a bit upset, and went to (get his mind off things?) play video games. I don't know what to do and am still thinking about it. We have at least until the end of the year when our lease is up and then I'd be free to move out (I also discussed with him that I am open to/maybe moving back to my parents').

What do you guys think? (Again, sorry it's so long! I just wanted to explain the situation and my feelings as clearly as possible.)
 
A few thoughts. You can never find the perfect partner, so you need to consider if you can put up with how things are; be patient until it changes; try different approaches to any perceived problems; and/or consider changes to your expectations. Also think about how would the relationship feel if these problems resolved, would it be good? Is it worth extra time and effort?
 
It honestly sounds like he is using you as a substitute mother/parent.

You have given him time to change and pull his weight around the house and contribute his fair share with the household finances, but nothing has changed.

If he walks off when you talk to him about it and does not make any plans to change his behavior, then he won't. From what you have written, it sounds like you would be better off moving when your lease is up.
 

grammarsweet

Well-known member
I stop reading at fourth paragraph...

"He also does not get things done that need to be done. For example: not cleaning up after himself regularly, not helping with household chores, not keeping track of important documents and things (he has a habit of losing/misplacing things), not saving enough funds to help with our monthly expenses, and not getting around to things he said he will do (either for himself or me, or both of us). Even when I remind him about things or ask him for help with something, he will say yes he will get it done but he never does. I also hate complaining and nagging him about things but he just never seems to take action or have any motivation to change. It is very frustrating. "

Clearly your relationship is going nowhere so instead of letting him drag you down get out of the relationship because it could be better to both of you. Helping him to get on his feet is okay but for how long will you do it? You have a life also.
 

awkwardamanda

Well-known member
In my experience, if you're having doubts about something, it's for a reason. That goes for life in general. Don't just stick around because it's familiar and convenient or because you don't think you'll find anyone else. You need time alone after a breakup anyway. It sounds like you guys are done. You even said you don't know if you love him anymore. I think money is the most common reason couples fight. This will tear you apart sooner or later. I think he needs to figure some stuff out for himself. He may need a rude awakening.


boyfriend? girlfriend? relationships? What are these words? I don't understand them.

Ha ha, yeah. I know how it is.
 

PugofCrydee

You want to know how I got these scars?
In some relationships there is one who has an easier ride because the other 'enables' their behavior. It's possible you are doing this, he may not be trying as hard as he should because you in effect are supporting him, mothering him, giving him a safety net.

So while you enable this behavior to continue, it will.

If it was me in your situation, I'd say we must live apart and support ourselves.

You can stay in the relationship with him but keep finances separate. This way he will have no option but to start doing the important things for himself.

The biggest thing here is, if you love him this will actually help him.
 

Xervello

Well-known member
I don't have any friends or anyone I feel comfortable talking to about this, so I am hoping you guys could give me some advice, opinions, or your past experiences. I have been in a relationship for about 3 years but for the past few months I have been thinking of whether I should break it off or not. I have no idea whether that would help or hurt me in the long run.

So we've had a pretty good relationship and have lived together for most of it (and are still living together). He was my first serious and long-term relationship, first true love, first person I've lived together with, and first (and only) intimate partner. I know he loves me, he has never cheated or been interested in anyone else, and he has never abused me in any way. He also knows I get very depressed and sometimes anxious and he is very supportive and empathetic about that; he has never made me feel ashamed about my disorders.

However, during the time we've been together he has not been able to get a job. He has tried applying to places and even going to interviews, but never lands a job. But he has barely any work experience and does not use employment opportunity/guidance resources available to him. He makes a low amount of money currently and is terrible managing his finances, we have talked about this and even worked out a budget to follow but he still spends all his money on things that aren't necessary. He has zero savings, is usually late to pay rent, and many times can't even come up with his share to pay for things like groceries (and owes me money for covering some of his expenses when he wasn't making enough to pay for himself, although he does pay me back small amounts when he can and has been trustworthy about it). This makes it very stressful on me, as I am a student and only work a part-time min wage job. I haven't even had enough to buy groceries the past few weeks and have been eating barely anything, or buying cheap snacks to eat when I can.

He also does not get things done that need to be done. For example: not cleaning up after himself regularly, not helping with household chores, not keeping track of important documents and things (he has a habit of losing/misplacing things), not saving enough funds to help with our monthly expenses, and not getting around to things he said he will do (either for himself or me, or both of us). Even when I remind him about things or ask him for help with something, he will say yes he will get it done but he never does. I also hate complaining and nagging him about things but he just never seems to take action or have any motivation to change. It is very frustrating.

I have talked with him multiple times about these issues and he says he knows and he's trying and feels bad and that he will try to change, etc. But things just stay the same, no matter what I tell him or do for him. I have also tried helping him many, many times to try to make things easier on him, including getting him job interviews, helping him with his resume, taking him out on dates/to do something together, helping him organize things and getting information/doing research on things for him to reach his goals, encouraging him, finding helpful/supportive resources or services he can use, etc. (He won't do these things himself!)

I know him well and I can see he wants to help. He is not using me or having bad intentions. He is a genuinely nice and caring person but he has difficulty getting started on things and achieving goals/being productive. He is in his mid-twenties and does not know what he wants as a career or how to go about finding the right path. (I can't even think of anything he would do well at and enjoy, especially because he never really did well in school subjects and does not have any passions that might guide him to a certain career, though he does want to go back to school...he just doesn't know for what.)

Sorry this is so long. It is complicated for me. Basically, our relationship isn't terrible, but it is not great either. I've done everything I can and given him lots of time but he still hasn't changed his ways. I am not sure if I love him anymore, but my life has also been very stressful lately so that may be why I feel a lack of emotion. I definitely don't feel like dating anyone else. If we broke up, I know I'd be depressed and would not want to date for a long time. I do care about him and enjoy being around him. We also share similar interests and get along well; we don't have many fights or anything and have mutual understanding of one another. He is also my best and only friend and the person I confide in the most, so it would be hard on me to let that go. I have tried to make new friends but it hasn't worked out, and I don't have anyone. I would move back in with my parents if we broke up and I think that would be less stressful. I do feel fed up and like I've done every possible thing I could to help my boyfriend be more productive and to make things work out living like this. Stress and frustration has been taking its toll on me and I do not feel a strong emotional connection with my boyfriend like I used to. I have told him how I feel and that I am done. I have told him how frustrated I am and what issues I have. He didn't respond much, just asked why and seemed confused and a bit upset, and went to (get his mind off things?) play video games. I don't know what to do and am still thinking about it. We have at least until the end of the year when our lease is up and then I'd be free to move out (I also discussed with him that I am open to/maybe moving back to my parents').

What do you guys think? (Again, sorry it's so long! I just wanted to explain the situation and my feelings as clearly as possible.)


It sounds like you've done everything possible to help him, and more than most would, but he's unwilling to change. Change is very difficult. But with the help of friends, family, a loved one, evolving slowly over time is not only possible but the natural course a reasonably able and/or thoughtful person will take. It doesn't sound like he's willing or capable to do this. And it also sounds like you might've left him a long time ago had you another person in your life with which to share things. Don't feel guilty about that. You're only human and you need things, too. Just as he needs to change, so too might you now in taking a chance on leaving him and trying to make it on your own. I understand how scary that can be, and it's something I've never been brave enough to do. However, I suspect you're equipped for it. Considering all the hard work, ambition and care you put into your life and his, I have no doubts you could do it. Who's to say if it's best for you in the short or long run. But settling for being miserable and worn out doesn't sound too appealing. I'd listen to what your gut is telling you. And I wish you luck. :)
 

SCP-087-1

Well-known member
I would suggest ending it. But make sure he knows why you're ending it. It might finally give him the motivation to improve himself. If he does improve himself don't take him back. At least not straight away. It would halt any progress he's made. So just be happy for him if he does make any changes and maybe a year or so down the track you can revisit the idea of a relationship with him. But this is being optimistic. In my experience, it's very rare that people change.

I know you love him but you wont get anywhere at this rate. You must have goals you want to achieve and it must be hard doing that when you have to be your boyfriends mother all the time.

I found it very hard to leave my first long term girlfriend and stayed with her way longer than I should have even though I knew I had to leave her. I think everyone feels very strongly about their first serious relationship and it's hard to let go of it.

I think a few people on this site might tell you to stay with him and accept him how he is because they can empathize with him. But, when it comes to relationships, I don't believe in just blindly accepting someone for how they are. That's how people get complacent and stop evolving. He should want to be a better man for you not just give up and make no effort
 
Top