Why do people feel the need to call me quiet?

FriendlyShadow

Well-known member
So, yesterday was my brother's birthday and my older sister out of nowhere asks me "why are you so quiet?" First of all, why can't some people understand that if I"m quiet, it just means I don't feel like talking, listening to what others say, or just thinking about something? Why do some people think it's a crime to be nice and when people aren't usually socializing? As for her little remark, I try to shrug it off, laugh about it as if it were some joke, but what I feel in the inside, I feel really frustrated and I just want to turn invisible.::(: I wonder how my sister feel if I told her in front of everybody how loud she was and that she never shuts up. I don't want to do that though because then I'll come across as disrespectful and mean. So, it's cool if she flat out tells me in front of everybody how quiet I am and even multiply asking why I am being quiet(which I don't think is necessary) or even telling me I'm too quiet, but if I were to tell her she's being loud or shut up, then I'll be looked down on and people will probably think I'm a jerk face. It's irritating!:mad: I don't know why she feels the need to tell me I'm quiet all the time. It might not be the same as a person calling me ugly or fat, but being called quiet is certainly not a compliment either. I did tell her something like "Oh, thank you" or "Yes, I love you too, Chris." But honestly, what I really did want to say was"Oh, I've been told that, but thanks for pointing that out" or "Because you never stop talking". But, I thought no, I'll just let it slide like I always do because it's always bound to happen every time she visits our house or if we go to her house or any other area. Can she not understand that I just don't feel like talking?! And not only that, but she had to bring it up again because we were jokingly talking about excrement and I wanted her to change the subject(because I think it was a little too much), but then here she goes saying "Well, you don't say anything. What do you want to talk about, pee?" I just thought to myself, you really want to go down that road, Chris? Anyways, I feel like every time she does this to me, I want to rip my whole hair out. I mean(to be honest)... it's just like asking somebody Why are you so fat, Why are you so short, Why are you so loud, Why are you so hot, ect. That gets annoying after awhile. Maybe I should just tell her I have dyspraxia(since she doesn't know obviously) and just end this stupid problem. Even better, why not just tell her this secret I've been keeping from her and these people that are around so it'll be more embarrassing. If she was ever placed in my shoes ,about how all of those kids treated me in school, being rejected and called quiet all the freaking time, maybe she understand how I felt. Or maybe she won't, because she'll never understand what I've been through and she'll always try to change me for who I am. Another thing that annoys be about her, is that every time I do try talk to her, she's the one giving me short responses and giving me at least one or two sentences. So, who is she to judge about my shyness if she can't hold a conversation with me?:confused: I don't understand her. And honestly, I think she does this because she thinks she is better than me and only cares about herself. Also, why tell me I'm quiet when I already know I am and I know myself better than anyone else? Does she think asking me why I'm quiet is and telling me I'm too quiet is going to help me open up more? I guess to her it does. -_- Plus, it's none of her business about me not socializing. I think she has to understand one day that if a person is quiet, it just means that they don't feel like talking or it could be any other problem they might be thinking of. Now, I could possibly understand if she called me quiet if I didn't respond to anyone's questions, or not saying an ENTIRE word to anyone and looking depressed, but I think she is just asking for it to be honest. Her telling me I'm quiet once is enough, I don't need to be reminded of my shyness everyday I go to see her like some tape recorder.
 

Csea88

Well-known member
My older sister does the exact same thing to me, and ironically she is very loud/outspoken and I tend to be quiet and shy, sounds like it's the dynamic how it ends up sometimes in some families but I understand what you're saying
 

MikeyC

Well-known member
To be fair, quietness can lead people to believe you're unhappy or not enjoying yourself so that's probably why she said it.

There's nothing wrong with being quiet and in large groups I am generally the same.
 

FriendlyShadow

Well-known member
To be fair, quietness can lead people to believe you're unhappy or not enjoying yourself so that's probably why she said it.

There's nothing wrong with being quiet and in large groups I am generally the same.

Not that I wasn't enjoying myself, I do laugh a lot at jokes most of the times or when we're around people and when we were at that birthday party. Either way, she'll still have the nerve to bring up my shyness.
 
Last edited:

MikeyC

Well-known member
Not that I wasn't enjoying myself, I do laugh alot at jokes most of the times or when we're around people and when we were at that birthday party. I just don't feel like talking.
True, but not joining in on conversations can be perceived as unhappiness. I don't think you're doing anything wrong, but neither are they. I can understand it gets tiring continually being asked why you're quiet, and that would get on anyone's nerves, really.
 

BleedTheFreak

Well-known member
I obviously can't tell you her intentions, but in general when people have asked me why I'm quiet they usually do it because they're trying to give me an opening or just trying to involve me in the conversation. I don't think people realize how stressful it can be to put us on the spot like that, but I think (in most cases) they mean well.
 

Pacific_Loner

Pirate from the North Pole
If it annoys you that much, maybe you should tell her. I had one person who would ask me why I'm so quiet all the time and at some point I got tired and told her how annoying it was and she eventually stopped. That wasn't complicated.
 

Roman Legion

Well-known member
I went to the movies yesterday with my brother and I wasn't talking because I couldn't.. He kept asking me why I was so quiet.. Luckily I had my ipod to reduce the anxiety and so I could stop hearing him.. Sometimes I swear I just want to go from my selective mutism to full on mute.. To me, it seems nobody ever has anything to say, they speak only to hear their own voice.. If only I could lose what voice I have basically at home and be forever silent.. A guy can dream, right?
 

ScaredToBreathe

Well-known member
I know exactly what you mean! I hate when people do that it makes me want to punch them in the face because they basically added insult to injury. they dont know how much it hurts to not have my voice when i need it and everything it's held me back from doing. I wish they could trade places for a day and see how it feels like to go that day with SA and SM barely talkin, feeling sick all the time, and not being able to hold even a small conversation

my own friend said in front of people we just met that i was shy. yea thanks a f**king lot, lotta help that does me! and she was the one who begged me to ask them to hang out cuz she was too scared to ask. i was the one who did all the talking that time. i think she said that to make her feel more talkative and better about herself w/o realizing how much it brings me down.

my "brother" (by blood at least) always insults me for being quiet. he is total opposite of me very nerdy and doesnt stfu for one second, and he's the most ignorant bastard in the world.

my managers at work call me quiet and shy and even ask me "whats wrong" but they just dont get why i cant talk at times.

so thanks a lot a**holes in my life if anything you made me talk less, NOT open up more. if you wanna me to talk, how bout instead of pointing out something obvious thats a problem about me, you actually start a conversation politely and ask about my interests, upcoming events, the weather, whatever!
 

ScaredToBreathe

Well-known member
Sometimes I swear I just want to go from my selective mutism to full on mute..

i feel this way too it feels like i'd have a better excuse for not talking if i was a mute, not just a SM. like people would be more understanding and accepting of that reason.
but i take it all back when my words do come out, especially around friends where i can just feel like normal again and talk.
 

Roman Legion

Well-known member
i feel this way too it feels like i'd have a better excuse for not talking if i was a mute, not just a SM. like people would be more understanding and accepting of that reason.
but i take it all back when my words do come out, especially around friends where i can just feel like normal again and talk.

I have been googling a way to destroy it, and I don't expect anyone to understand why I am looking for it.. Just not finding any results either.. I'd hit my own throat if I didn't think it would be suicide.. I think I am going to scream for an extended period of time when my throat is VERY dry and nobody is home.. I know that will at least damage it.. Damage over time on anything only gets worse, right?
 

MikeyC

Well-known member
I went to the movies yesterday with my brother and I wasn't talking because I couldn't.. He kept asking me why I was so quiet.. Luckily I had my ipod to reduce the anxiety and so I could stop hearing him.. Sometimes I swear I just want to go from my selective mutism to full on mute.. To me, it seems nobody ever has anything to say, they speak only to hear their own voice.. If only I could lose what voice I have basically at home and be forever silent.. A guy can dream, right?
Maybe you're not talking to the right people?
 

ScaredToBreathe

Well-known member
I have been googling a way to destroy it, and I don't expect anyone to understand why I am looking for it.. Just not finding any results either.. I'd hit my own throat if I didn't think it would be suicide.. I think I am going to scream for an extended period of time when my throat is VERY dry and nobody is home.. I know that will at least damage it.. Damage over time on anything only gets worse, right?

you shouldn't get rid of your voice :( yes it can be troublesome sometimes but you may need it sometime and as unlikely as it may seem your SM may even get better and you'd be able to talk a bit more. but whether its heard or not your voice is a part of you, it's something you've always had, so dont waste it..use it when you need to the most.
 

Roman Legion

Well-known member
you shouldn't get rid of your voice :( yes it can be troublesome sometimes but you may need it sometime and as unlikely as it may seem your SM may even get better and you'd be able to talk a bit more. but whether its heard or not your voice is a part of you, it's something you've always had, so dont waste it..use it when you need to the most.

I only talk at home, but I can easily learn sign langauge.. I despise verbal communication so much.. All we are in the end are our memories, my voice in private is a memory, now like a traitor, I want to destroy it. I don't want to work my way out of SM, I want it to be even more dominant to the point of full on mute.. As odd as that may sound..
 

MikeyC

Well-known member
I only talk at home, but I can easily learn sign langauge.. I despise verbal communication so much.. All we are in the end are our memories, my voice in private is a memory, now like a traitor, I want to destroy it. I don't want to work my way out of SM, I want it to be even more dominant to the point of full on mute.. As odd as that may sound..
Hmm. Do you find it difficult to type your thoughts and "talk" to us here?
 

Roman Legion

Well-known member
Hmm. Do you find it difficult to type your thoughts and "talk" to us here?

Since it is a very impersonal form of communication where emotion is hard to convey at ties; no, I don't find it all that difficult.. I have things in my past that I will likely never discuss with anyone in any way.. (Text or sign)
 

MikeyC

Well-known member
Since it is a very impersonal form of communication where emotion is hard to convey at ties; no, I don't find it all that difficult.. I have things in my past that I will likely never discuss with anyone in any way.. (Text or sign)
Oh, that's not what I was getting at, and there are things from my past that will stay in my head, too. At least you find typing easier than talking.
 
Top